Scholarship Management Simplified.
Scale your impact without scaling your workload.
Reviewr streamlines the entire scholarship management process from application to scholar selection. Eliminate spreadsheet chaos and disconnected processes to reduce scholarship management time by 73%, and focus on what matters most – creating impact and changing lives.
🎓 Scholarship Program Compliance Assessment
32-Point Comprehensive Checklist for Scholarship Organizations
Assessment Progress
Legal & IRS
Program Design
Application
Selection
Financial
Technology
Risk & Legal
Overall Risk Score
--
Not Started
Compliance Score
--
Not Assessed
Vulnerabilities
0
Identified
⚖️ Legal & IRS Compliance
High Priority 1. Is your organization properly qualified as a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt organization or public charity?
Only qualified 501(c)(3) organizations can offer tax-deductible scholarship contributions and avoid tax penalties.
Recommendation: File Form 1023 or 1023-EZ with the IRS to obtain tax-exempt status. Private foundations need IRS advance approval for scholarship programs.
2. Do you maintain proper documentation to support your charitable class requirements?
IRS requires scholarships serve a sufficiently broad charitable class, not just specific individuals or families.
Recommendation: Document how your eligibility criteria serve a public charitable purpose and benefit a sufficiently large class of potential recipients.
3. Are your scholarship selection procedures objective and non-discriminatory?
Federal law and IRS regulations require fair, objective selection processes that comply with anti-discrimination laws.
Recommendation: Establish written selection criteria, use scoring rubrics, and ensure selection committees follow consistent procedures for all applicants.
4. Do you comply with Title VI, Title IX, and other federal anti-discrimination laws?
Title VI prohibits race/national origin discrimination, Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in education programs.
Recommendation: Train staff on federal anti-discrimination laws and review all eligibility criteria to ensure compliance with civil rights requirements.
5. Are scholarship awards properly documented for tax reporting purposes?
Organizations must report scholarship payments that exceed qualified educational expenses on Form 1099-MISC.
Recommendation: Maintain detailed records of all scholarship payments and issue appropriate tax forms for amounts exceeding tuition, fees, and required books/supplies.
📋 Program Design & Governance
High Priority 6. Are your scholarship eligibility criteria clearly defined and transparent?
Clear eligibility criteria help ensure fair access and reduce legal challenges while improving applicant experience.
Recommendation: Publish detailed, easy-to-understand eligibility requirements on your website and application materials, including GPA, income limits, field of study, and geographic restrictions.
7. Do you have written policies governing scholarship administration and award processes?
Written policies ensure consistent administration and provide legal protection for your organization.
Recommendation: Develop comprehensive scholarship policies covering application procedures, selection criteria, disbursement methods, and renewal requirements.
8. Are selection committee members free from conflicts of interest?
IRS requires that selection committee members cannot have economic benefit from scholarship decisions.
Recommendation: Require conflict of interest disclosures from all committee members and establish recusal procedures when conflicts arise.
9. Do you monitor scholarship recipients' use of funds and academic progress?
Monitoring ensures charitable funds are used properly and helps track program effectiveness.
Recommendation: Require periodic progress reports from recipients and verify enrollment status before disbursing renewal funds.
10. Do you have procedures for recovering improperly used scholarship funds?
Organizations have a fiduciary duty to recover charitable funds that are misused or obtained through fraud.
Recommendation: Include clawback provisions in scholarship agreements and establish procedures for investigating and recovering misused funds.
📝 Application Process & Accessibility
Medium Priority 11. Do you provide a user-friendly, accessible online application system?
Accessible applications ensure equal opportunity for students with disabilities and improve application completion rates.
Recommendation: Use online application platforms that comply with ADA requirements, offer mobile compatibility, and include save-and-return functionality.
12. Are application deadlines reasonable and well-publicized?
Clear deadlines with adequate notice help ensure all qualified students have opportunity to apply.
Recommendation: Publicize deadlines at least 60 days in advance across multiple channels including high schools, colleges, and community organizations.
13. Do you collect only necessary personal and financial information?
Collecting excessive personal information can violate privacy laws and create unnecessary security risks.
Recommendation: Limit data collection to information directly relevant to eligibility and selection criteria, and clearly explain why each piece of information is needed.
14. Do you provide application assistance for underserved communities?
Application assistance helps ensure equity and access for first-generation college students and underrepresented groups.
Recommendation: Partner with high schools, community centers, and libraries to provide application workshops and technical assistance.
🎯 Selection & Evaluation Process
High Priority 15. Do you use standardized scoring rubrics for fair evaluation?
Standardized rubrics ensure consistent, objective evaluation and provide legal protection against discrimination claims.
Recommendation: Develop weighted scoring rubrics that align with your program goals and train all reviewers on consistent application of criteria.
16. Do you implement blind review processes to reduce bias?
Blind review reduces unconscious bias and promotes more equitable selection decisions.
Recommendation: Remove or redact identifying information such as names, school names, and photos during the initial review phase.
17. Are your review committees diverse and representative?
Diverse review committees help ensure fair representation and reduce groupthink in selection decisions.
Recommendation: Include reviewers from different backgrounds, professions, and perspectives, including former scholarship recipients when possible.
18. Do you maintain detailed records of all selection decisions?
Detailed records help defend against challenges and provide insights for program improvement.
Recommendation: Document all scores, comments, and rationale for selection decisions, and retain records for at least 7 years.
19. Do you provide meaningful feedback to unsuccessful applicants?
Constructive feedback helps applicants improve future applications and demonstrates transparency in your process.
Recommendation: Provide general feedback on areas for improvement and information about other scholarship opportunities when possible.
💰 Financial Management & Controls
High Priority 20. Do you disburse scholarship funds directly to educational institutions?
Direct payments to schools help ensure funds are used for educational purposes and may reduce tax liability for recipients.
Recommendation: Establish direct payment procedures with educational institutions to ensure proper use of scholarship funds and maintain appropriate documentation.
21. Do you verify student enrollment before disbursing funds?
Enrollment verification prevents fraud and ensures scholarship funds support active students.
Recommendation: Require official enrollment verification from the educational institution before each disbursement, including course load and enrollment status.
22. Are your financial controls adequate to prevent fraud and misuse?
Strong financial controls protect charitable assets and maintain donor confidence in your organization.
Recommendation: Implement segregation of duties, require multiple approvals for payments above set thresholds, and conduct regular financial audits.
23. Do you maintain detailed financial records and donor stewardship?
Proper financial reporting builds trust with donors and ensures compliance with accounting standards.
Recommendation: Provide regular financial reports to donors showing how their contributions are being used and the impact achieved.
🔒 Technology & Data Security
High Priority 24. Do you use secure, encrypted systems for collecting and storing applicant data?
Secure data storage is required by GDPR, CCPA, and other privacy laws that protect student information.
Recommendation: Use enterprise-grade security with encryption, access controls, SOC 2 compliance, and regular security audits for all applicant data.
25. Do you have automated systems to streamline application processing?
Automation reduces errors, improves efficiency, and provides better tracking of application status.
Recommendation: Implement scholarship management software with automated workflows, eligibility screening, and status notifications for applicants.
26. Do you comply with student privacy laws like FERPA and state privacy regulations?
FERPA protects student educational records, while state laws like CCPA provide additional privacy protections.
Recommendation: Train staff on privacy requirements, implement data retention policies, and provide clear privacy notices to applicants.
27. Do you have robust backup and disaster recovery procedures?
Data loss can disrupt scholarship programs and create legal liability for lost applicant information.
Recommendation: Implement automated daily backups with off-site storage and test recovery procedures regularly to ensure data protection.
28. Do you track program metrics and outcomes with data analytics?
Data analytics help demonstrate program impact to stakeholders and identify opportunities for improvement.
Recommendation: Use dashboards to track application trends, award distributions, recipient outcomes, and program ROI for continuous improvement.
🛡️ Risk Management & Legal Protection
Medium Priority 29. Do you have adequate insurance coverage including D&O and cyber liability?
Insurance protects against legal claims, data breaches, and other risks that could threaten your organization.
Recommendation: Review insurance coverage annually to ensure adequate protection for directors, officers, cyber incidents, and general liability.
30. Do you have procedures for handling complaints and appeals?
Fair complaint procedures protect your organization's reputation and provide due process for applicants.
Recommendation: Establish clear complaint and appeal procedures with timelines, review processes, and documentation requirements.
31. Are you prepared for potential audits or regulatory investigations?
State and federal agencies may audit scholarship programs for compliance with tax and anti-discrimination laws.
Recommendation: Maintain organized records, designate audit response staff, and conduct periodic internal compliance reviews.
32. Do you regularly review and update your compliance procedures?
Regular compliance reviews help identify gaps and ensure procedures remain current with changing laws.
Recommendation: Conduct annual compliance reviews, stay updated on regulatory changes, and engage legal counsel for complex compliance issues.
🎯 Assessment Complete!
Your Scholarship Program Compliance Assessment Results
Overall Risk Score
--
--
Compliance Score
--
--
Vulnerabilities
0
Identified
Category Breakdown
📊 Overall Assessment
⚠️ Critical Vulnerabilities
✅ Compliance Strengths
🎯 Priority Actions
📋 90-Day Implementation Action Plan
🚀 How Modern Scholarship Management Platforms Can Help
Based on your assessment results, a comprehensive scholarship management platform can help you:
Why Reviewr
Reviewr is a scholarship management platform built for modern, mission driven, organizations. We replace your scattered spreadsheets, disconnected tools, endless emails, and manual processes with one unified system that handles the entire scholarship lifecycle—from accepting applications to measuring long-term impact. The result? Your team spends less time on administration and more time making a difference.
84%Less time managing scholarships
Automated workflows eliminate manual data entry, email coordination, and spreadsheet updates—giving your team back 20+ hours every week.
5xFaster review cycles
Collaborative scoring, side-by-side comparisons, and automated reviewer assignments turn months-long processes into weeks.
94%Complete impact visibility
Real-time dashboards and automated scholar impact reporting mean you always know exactly how your scholarships are performing.
Solving real challenges
Take a quick tour
The Scholarship Applicant Experience
Empower scholarship applicants with the modern and user friendly experience they desire – promoting more engaged participants, increased participation rates, better quality applications, and reduced support.
Optimize your scholarship program’s online presence with Reviewr’s landing pages, designed exclusively for scholarship management and the needs of scholarship providers. These landing pages are more than just a digital experience; they’re an integral part of Reviewrs comprehensive scholarship software. Landing pages are crafted to highlight scholarship details such as important dates and deadlines to eligibility criteria, ensuring all pertinent information is accessible and clear. Landing pages embrace your brand’s identity, allowing for primary and secondary color control to align with your style guide. Highlight your sponsors with dedicated spaces for logos, enhancing credibility and connection with your audience. With Reviewr’s scholarship management system, create a seamless, engaging experience for your applicants while maintaining the professional look and feel of your program.
Streamline the scholarship application process with Reviewr’s intuitive and robust scholarship application functions. Designed with both scholarship applicants and scholarship managers in mind, Reviewer simplifies the submission process, allowing applicants to provide all necessary information efficiently and accurately. If you can dream it up, the Reviewr scholarship application form builder can power it.
Scholarship applicant profiles are a core component to the Reviewr scholarship management software. Profiles empower scholarship applicants to create and manage their information, centralizing their scholarship journey from the initial application to final selection and more. Profiles enable scholarship applicants to apply to multiple scholarships, submit necessary files and deliverables, add additional content tailored to different program stages of the scholarship process, receive communication, and access scholarship selection results.
Supplemental forms are an exciting and innovating new feature to Reviewr. Supplemental forms enable scholarship applicants to either request additional information from external sources or add additional submission forms to their profile for different stages of the scholarship process. Supplemental forms are often used to collect reference requests and transcripts directly from the source. Scholarship applicants can also access their scholarship profile and add dedicated forms/deliverables requested by scholarship providers at different stages of the program.
The Scholarship Management Experience
Increase scholarship management efficiency by an average of 84%, saving time and money that can be better allocated to other high-impact activities. Manage the entire scholarship lifecycle in one place with a dedicated scholarship management system – eliminating the back and fourth between paper, email, web forms, spreadsheets, exporting, databases, file sharing, and more.
Transform your scholarship administration with Reviewr’s Scholarship Manager Dashboard, the command center at the heart of our scholarship management software. Leverage the dashboard for real time monitoring of dates, deadlines, and activities. Navigate to dedicated scholarship management tools such as managing users, creating workflows, viewing scholarship applications, communicating with both applicants and staff, generating reports, and much more.
Easily search, filter, and sort scholarship applications from the scholarship management software. Designed for efficiency, scholarship providers can view scholarship applicant profiles, view submitted scholarship applications, access files and deliverables, communicate with scholars, leave internal notes, and more!
Streamline your review process with Reviewr’s dynamic feature for assigning scholarship applicants to review committees, a vital tool within our comprehensive scholarship management software. This feature offers versatile assignment options to accommodate your program’s unique needs, ensuring a fair and unbiased evaluation process. Manually assign individual scholarship applications to specific committee members for a tailored review approach, or utilize groupings to distribute batches of applications efficiently among different reviewers. For a more impartial distribution, leverage the automated assignment system, which randomly allocates a set number of submissions to judges, mitigating potential biases and promoting a fair assessment environment. This assignment flexibility ensures that each application is reviewed thoroughly and fairly, enhancing the integrity and credibility of your scholarship program.
With Reviewr, simplify your review process while maintaining a high standard of fairness and transparency in applicant evaluation.
The Scholarship Review Experience
Reduce scholarship evaluation workloads by 79% and promote a professional and time-conscious online review and selection experience resulting in higher quality reviews, feedback, and increased year over volunteer retention. Ensure program integrity and confidence through non-bias, accurate, transparent, consistent, and data-driven decision-making.
Elevate your scholarship review process with Reviewr’s online review and selection tools, an essential part of our scholarship management software designed to enhance efficiency and decision-making. This feature empowers review committee members to sort, filter, find, and view detailed information on scholarship applicants seamlessly. Looking to blind data, don’t worry – scholarship providers have direct control over what data is visible to review teams.
Maximize the effectiveness of your scholarship review process with Reviewr’s innovative side-by-side interface, a key feature of our scholarship management software that creates significant efficiency for review team workflows. This intuitive interface allows review committees to simultaneously view scholarship applicant profiles and materials alongside an online scorecard/selection tool, streamlining the evaluation process. This side-by-side approach helps minimize switching between forms, documents, notes, and scoresheets for an engaging experience.
Reviewr offers embedded document viewing experience significantly improves the scholarship review workflow for review teams. The seamless integration ensures that all necessary materials and files are accessible directly in Reviewr without having to download and open in external tools. This approach ensures the ability to conduct side-by-side review in a centralized scholarship management software.
What would be a scholarship management software without a dedicated portal to view results for data driven decision making? Eliminate complicated spreadsheets and manual tabulations. The real-time decision making tools provide an overview of the applicants, who reviewed them, how they were reviewed, total scores, and averages. Seamlessly advance applicants to different workflows or leverage the data for informed decision making.
