Webinar
Upcoming

Would Your Grant Scores Hold Up? Building a Rubric Your Board Can Defend

Build a weighted grant rubric with clear score levels and a reason behind every score, so each decision holds up.

event
November 25, 2026
schedule
12:30 pm

Score Every Grant Proposal So the Decision Explains Itself

A 30-minute session for grantmakers on four parts of a grant rubric that holds up when a board member, an auditor or a declined applicant asks why. Every registrant gets a rubric template to fill in with your own criteria.

Funding priorities shift. In a September 2026 study by the Center for Effective Philanthropy, 93% of the 183 foundation leaders surveyed had changed their approach that year, and the most common change, reported by 62%, was concentrating funding in the areas of greatest need.

When priorities shift, the rubric has to shift with them. Often it stays the same. Criteria like "community impact" and "organizational capacity" get scored 1 to 10 with no weights and no description of what each score means, so every reviewer fills in the gaps with their own judgment.

This session is built around two of the five dimensions of Review Integrity, a framework for judging whether an application and review process is fair, consistent and defensible.

The first is Rubric Clarity: are your criteria written, weighted and visible before anyone applies? When a rubric doesn't say what a 3 or a 5 means, two careful reviewers can score the same proposal for different reasons.

The second is Decision Traceability: can any funding decision be reconstructed and defended? If the only record of why a proposal finished fourth is the number itself, the reasons are gone the moment someone asks.

When the rubric can't explain the result, someone has to. Declined applicants get a form letter instead of a real answer. Board questions get settled from memory, in the meeting. And over time, awards drift from the priorities the board approved, with no clear way to see where it happened.

Grant rounds run on fiscal years and letter-of-inquiry cycles. Whatever rubric is in place when a round opens is what every proposal gets scored against, and what you'll point to when someone asks why.

In This 30-Minute Session, You'll Learn How To:

  • Weight your criteria so the priorities your board set count most in the score
  • Describe what a low, middle and high score looks like for each criterion
  • Set a simple comment rule, so every score has a reason behind it
  • Run a conflict check before scoring, so reviewers don't score organizations they're connected to
  • Keep each proposal's scores, comments and final decision together, ready for a board or auditor question
  • Give declined applicants an answer based on the rubric, not a form letter

You'll also see how Reviewr's team builds your program from the forms and rubric you already use, in about 30 days.

What You'll Get

The Grant Rubric Template, with weighted criteria, score levels, a comment rule and a conflict check you can fill in for your own program.

Who Should Attend

Grantmakers running competitive grant programs: program officers, grants managers, executive directors and grants committee chairs at private, family, community and corporate foundations, plus public and economic development funders.

FAQ

Does a weighted rubric replace your committee's judgment? No. Reviewers still read every proposal and score it, and your committee still makes the final decisions. A clear rubric makes sure everyone is scoring against the same priorities, and that each score has a reason you can point to later.

Can Reviewr keep reviewers off proposals they're connected to? Yes. You decide which reviewers see which proposals, so you can keep anyone off a proposal from an organization they're connected to.

Does Reviewr send grant payments? No. Reviewr runs intake, review and follow-up, such as grant agreements, grantee reports and receipts. It doesn't send payments or track fund balances. You can export a recipient report for your finance team.

‍