Check member eligibility, collect every judge's scores in one place and see winners by category before awards week.
For many award programs, the hardest week isn't judging. It's the week after. Judges' scores arrive as separate spreadsheets and emails, and someone on staff copies them into one master file, category by category. Membership gets checked by hand, sometimes after a winner is already picked. Close categories get settled late, and winner names, titles and companies get typed into the program from months-old nomination forms.
By awards night, that master file is often the only record of who won and why, and one person built it.
This session draws on two of the five dimensions of Review Integrity, a framework for judging whether an application and review process is fair, consistent and defensible.
The first is Decision Traceability: can any award decision be reconstructed and defended? If a member asks how a winner was chosen, the scores, the judges and the reasons should be in one record, not in a file rebuilt the week before the event.
The second is Reviewer Calibration: are judges scoring against the same criteria, and is it clear when one judge scores much harder or easier than the rest? In a close category, one judge's habits can decide the outcome unless someone checks.
When results come together by hand in the final week, small mistakes reach the stage. A nominee who wasn't eligible wins. One copy-and-paste error changes a result. A close category is decided by a single harsh judge. Staff spend the week before the event tallying instead of preparing to host, and the decision behind the association's biggest night rests on a file only one person understands.
Award nominations typically run from fall into late winter. Who's eligible, how judges score and where results come together all get set before nominations close.
You'll also see how Reviewr's team builds your awards from the nomination forms and scoring sheets you already use, in about 30 days.
Association executives, awards and events staff, membership and programs teams, and awards committee chairs who run judged member awards: business awards at chambers of commerce, REALTOR® of the Year and other member awards at REALTOR® associations, and recognition awards at professional and trade associations.
Anyone can nominate, but only members can win. Does that still work?Yes. Nominations stay open to anyone, and membership questions on the nomination form flag a nominee who isn't eligible, so staff review it long before awards week.
We hold judging in person. Is this only for online judging?No. Judges can score on their own screens at home or in the room on judging day, or on paper, and every score goes into the same record. The session covers both.
Some of our awards come with a cash prize. Does Reviewr handle payments?No. Reviewr runs the nominations, judging and winner follow-up, like acceptances, headshots and bios. It doesn't send award payments or track balances. You download a winner report for whoever handles payment.
We only get a handful of nominations per category. Is this worth 30 minutes?Yes. Most of the session is judging and results practice you can use with any number of nominations and any tools.